Fixing the 3-5 Care Gap

When my first child was born, I had been freelancing for three years and like many, assumed I’d figure out how to manage both, including the inconsistencies of self-employment. While I was getting used to planning for constant shifts in work time and income, I hadn’t anticipated adding the stress of constant search for childcare.

As my due date approached, I felt new parent excitement and nervousness mixed with career apprehension. Instead of asking my boss for parental leave, as my other pregnant friends were, I worried if I’d be able to continue building my business while taking care of a baby. Knowing that project work comes and goes with unpredictable hours and schedules, would working for myself while parenting be sustainable? 

For the first six months I juggled both with the help of a part-time nanny for the 15 hours a week I could afford to continue working. 

By the time my son was two and I had more work, he was eligible for a local preschool five days a week. This worked well for two years. The nonprofit preschool offered care until 5:00 for an additional fee giving me the flexibility I needed while staying affordable.  But unfortunately, the preschool wasn’t ready to expand its capacity beyond 3-year-olds without a guaranteed income stream from government contracts, outside of its federally funded Headstart, which is limited to qualified families with little to no income.  

The spring that my son turned four, I had four months left to work and then I’d have to quit altogether or cut back my availability to maintain part-time help. Mayor DeBlasio’s massive expansion of “PreK for All” hadn’t kicked in yet and there were very few PreK seats in our local school District, “D1”, a small neighborhood that includes the Lower East Side, East Village and parts of Chinatown. District1 has always been a diverse neighborhood in many ways that I appreciate, while consistently being home to a high proportion of low income and working-class families.  Families who need reliable and affordable childcare.

At the last minute we were assigned a PreK seat in a neighborhood elementary school. Relief meant we could save $20,000 a year we were otherwise spending on care. And our son could also stay onsite for low-cost afterschool until 5:00 whenever we needed it. 

Fix the time gap

By kindergarten, we lost our low-cost afterschool due to city budget cuts and once again, parents, me included, scrambled to find alternatives so we could still work. 

I spent the next few years donating time and talent to cobble together a parent-led afterschool program that would meet the needs and budgets of our families. I learned a lot about the complexity of childcare and afterschool programs and can appreciate the reluctance of small providers entering this business, despite overwhelming need across the city. The high-touch, highly regulated landscape of afterschool care for young children that meets parents’ needs is one of the most difficult business propositions.  But it’s also one of the most urgent.

In his last year as mayor, Eric Adams promised to add 20,000 afterschool slots (Chalkbeat online Nov. 18, 2025) for K-5th grade students phased in over three years. Following standard policy, his plan did not include PreK or 3K children, even those enrolled in schools.

In January 2026, Governor Hochul announced support for Mayor Mamdani’s “…goal of expanding childcare to all 4-year-olds statewide by the fall of 2028. …[enabling] Mr. Mamdani to make New York City’s preschool program for 3-year-olds, known as 3-K, truly universal, and create a new free childcare system for the city’s 2-year-olds” (NY Times online Jan. 6, 2026) is welcome but it falls short. Current policy doesn’t support care for 3- and 4-year-olds after 3:00.

Working while parenting is no longer an either or for most of us while opting out of parenthood is becoming more common. Mamdani’s vision and Hochul’s commitment could offer an opportunity to create a unified continuum of education that includes afterschool care for all children enrolled in public school. As a working parent who has experienced and studied New York’s complicated education/childcare systems for over ten years in a high needs district, I know we need more afterschool spots, especially in under-resourced neighborhoods. We also need a unified early childcare and education system that bridges the gaps between 3pm and 5pm.

We need a continuum of care based on a standard workday[1] that brings together and coordinates polices and funding for public school expansions (adding more UPK and 3K seats, especially in high need neighborhoods) and afterschool care until 5pm for all ages. This can happen with a sustainable funding model that braids together federal grants, state and local tax revenues while exploring additional unconventional financing from philanthropies (as charter schools do) and sliding scale fees (like private childcare and afterschool programs).

Fix the Age Gap

Despite the city’s massive addition of Universal PreK seats in 2014, and recent addition of 3K seats and https://www.myschools.nyc/en/funding for more afterschool spots, parents must continue scrambling to pick up their kids at 2:30 if they are in 3K or PreK.[2] 

Part of this systemic breakdown is due to siloed effects of multiple city agencies managing regulations and funding related to children’s day by age and hour. School day hours are managed by the NYC Public Schools (NYCPS, FKA Department of Education) while time outside of school is managed by the Department of Youth and Community Development, for children in kindergarten and up while NYC Administration for Children manages vouchers for childcare- each with different funding sources, different missions, different regulations and different rules that don’t always align.

While almost half of 800 elementary schools start in 3K, the City-funded afterschool contracts officially exclude 3K and PreK students in those schools (MySchools and DYCD contract data released through the NYC OpenData portal January 2026.) In some cases, an entire school district officially reports no city funded afterschool for any of its PreK or 3K children. A search on the NYCPS website re-direct to the DYCD website.

A recent call I made to the District1 school office confirmed this frustrating rule.

Me: Hi, I’m calling to find out which elementary schools in Dist. 1 with PreK seats have after school programs.

D1: None of the DOE [NYCPS] public schools in D1 have 3K or PreK afterschool. Afterschool only starts in Kindergarten; Some schools may have a fee-based afterschool for earlier grades. But you would need to call each school you are interested in to find out more.

Me: So my child can't get afterschool until kindergarten, unless the school offers a fee-based afterschool for PreK?

D1: Correct - because of the age, they have different requirements such as potty training and feeding.

 

If a school is licensed for 3- and 4-year-olds until 3:00, why don’t the regulations align with the push for 3K and PreK?  Moreover, finding care should be easier than calling every individual provider, assuming parents even know who care providers are in their neighborhood.

Hope and innovation

Fortunately, the new mayoral administration has already begun to address some challenges by bringing in Emmy Liss as Executive Director of the first Mayoral Office of Child Care. Liss has dedicated more than 10 years to advocating for solutions to affordable childcare and early childhood education. She’s worked inside and alongside city government pushing for equitable childcare agendas.  As the head of the newly created Child Care office, I hope that one of her tasks will be untangling the afterschool childcare web of rules and funds so that we can maximize resources to offer more care options.

The Office of Child Care’s recent launch of Child Care Finder -a free tool for locating licensed child care providers by neighborhood is a major game changer.  That the challenge of finding care is being tackled is a positive sign that they are listening. Which parents they are listening to is not yet clear. The priorities are still fragmented and lacking a wholistic vision of education and care that lasts until 5 for families at all income levels. 

Solutions for finding childcare is also being addressed by the United Federation of Teachers -a major partner in the afterschool ecosystem. In October 2025 they announced the release of their Child Care Navigator.  The UFT tool has a more robust interface that allows for many more filters. For example, searching for providers that stay open until 6pm along with the number of spots available. It also has a built-in messaging app to make the process more efficient for parents who are time broke.

Given the progress that has been made so far with the co-operation of state and local leaders to address our need for more affordable city-wide childcare, I am hoping the gap from 3-5 will be closed by 2029.

Are two more hours too much to ask for?

[1] NYCPS refers to a 6-hour school day as a “full day.”

[2] NYC’s afterschool programs have evolved and expanded significantly since 2005 with Out of School Time (OST); and the Schools Out NYC (SONYC) initiative that focused on giving middle school students social activities after school. The current afterschool system, COMPASS (Comprehensive Afterschool System) is beginning to include academic intervention that is mostly co-located within public schools.

Previous
Previous

Losing Franks

Next
Next

Abandoned by government. Saved by humanity.